Monday, August 20, 1984

The Aftermath

It's been a few days since I quit. Most of my thoughts revolve around how my job at Best Buy was a lot of fun, challenging and quite an accomplishment. When I came up with this idea I didn't really think I could pull it off. From the resume embellishment to the background checks, to the interviews, to the waiting game and finally to the actual execution - it required a lot of acting. And amazingly, I didn't give myself away and kept my mouth shut the whole time.

I'll definitely miss Frito The Mad Hand Crusher as well as Rma and Darius and Braxton. I'll even miss Dick. I won't miss Myra. I wonder if I'll ever run into any of them again? If it's a few years from now I'm definitely telling them the real story.

But then again, what's the point? Do I really need to have their approval or impress them by showing I'm not a part time retail worker who can't even work a cash register? My ego isn't that big. I would probably just tell them I got a job at Circuit City.

As far as my initial objectives for Project Blue Shirt, I learned more than I ever could have imagined. There's nothing like throwing yourself into a totally unfamiliar situation and trying to assimilate. I'd like to do much more of this type of research. There's no way I could have gotten the real story by interviewing sales associates or store managers. I had to see it to believe it.

Account planning needs to get the hell out of the ad agency to have any real effect. We're supposed to bring the real world in, and we can't do that without being out in it. One of the main reasons I got into this game was due to my interest in people and how they act. Don't get me wrong, portfolio architecture presentations and quantitative testing results are thrilling, just a little disconnected from the real. And as we all know, most of the advertising community forgot what "real" is a long time ago.

Gonzo planning - or narrative planning - is the way to go. Interacting with the world is energizing. Observing the world as a "researcher" is restrictive and ultimately alienating. It's time to inject more of our personalities in our jobs.

Some summary learnings:

  • I hate to say this, but if I was just going on my Best Buy experience I'd say brands are overrated. The only brand that people asked for was Sony because they knew it growing up. Otherwise this category is driven by price. People can't tell the difference in quality - the TVs almost all look the same. Brand names teeter on the edge of irrelevancy.
  • The employee culture is well defined and vibrant. Best Buy has done a good job fostering a positive atmosphere, where employees are friends. There is a feeling that you can let your personality hang out, as long as you do a good job. And while commission isn't a motivation, there is friendly competition to see who can sell the most performance service plans and overall systems. And don't forget about store loyalty. It's almost collegiate in it's intensity. Employees are inspired to be creative and this builds loyalty.
  • Employees like to get spiffed. Any brand representative that comes into the store with a toy, coupon, even a pen is considered Santa Claus. Why doesn't everyone do this? Is it even legal? For a company that doesn't pay their employees commission, spiffing is the way to set yourself apart. It's subtle, but effective.
  • There's no damn training. Nothing to school me about product differences, features, etc. If they combined spiffing with some kind of training, they might have something.
  • Customers comes in all shapes and sizes - both mentally and physically. To be a Best Buy employee you need to be prepared. There is a skill in finding common ground with people and for the most part these employees are good at it. And they need to be because customers are confused. As technology races ahead, there is a greater division between customers and salespeople. The customers almost have to trust you because they are either so confused by information overload gleaned from the net, or they just don't want to know the details. There are more similarities than differences among the public. Mainly, most have combination of anxiety and excitement when they walk in the store. It can be fun for them, but it can also be as mentally taxing as a salesperson's job.

The impact of Best Buy on American culture is pretty remarkable. From The 40-Year-Old Virgin to the wealth of videos on youtube, Best Buy represents a unique gathering place that can bring out the best and worst in people. But the company encourages its employees to be lighthearted and open to all personalities. They view the world as a positive place. This attitude makes customers feel like they can linger and explore in a fun environment.

Of course, I'll never forget the experience. I'll never forget Frito, Myra, Darius, Rma, the "I don't want him!" lady and the Vudu girl. I'll never forget to not put my hands in my pockets on the job.

And most importantly, I'll never listen to the Village People the same way again.

No comments: